Smell Marks and Non-Traditional Trademarks: The UK Legal Landscape

Smell Marks and Non-Traditional Trademarks: The UK Legal Landscape

Non-traditional trademarks UK protection covers sounds, colours, shapes, smells and motion, not just words and logos. Smell marks are the hardest of all: no UK smell mark has been registered since the EU’s Sieckmann ruling in 2002 tightened the representation rules. ApexCounsel explains what can actually be registered in 2026, what the case law says, and when a non-traditional mark is worth the cost.

What Counts as a Non-Traditional Trademark Under UK Law?

A non-traditional trademark is any UK Intellectual Property Office (IPO) registration for a sign other than a word or a plain logo, such as a sound, a colour, a shape, a smell, a motion sequence or a hologram. Of the 203,194 trademark applications filed at the UK IPO in 2025, a record year up 17.3% on 2024, the overwhelming majority were conventional word or figurative marks; non-traditional filings remain a small fraction of the total, according to IPO facts and figures.

Section 1(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1994 defines a trademark broadly as any sign capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one business from another. That definition has always been wide enough to cover sounds, colours and shapes in principle. What has changed is how easy each type is to represent clearly enough for the IPO’s register, and that difficulty varies enormously between categories.

Businesses searching for non-traditional trademarks UK guidance are usually trying to protect a brand asset a competitor cannot easily copy with a simple rebrand, such as a distinctive jingle, a signature colour or an unusual product shape. The appeal is obvious. The legal bar to clear, as the rest of this article sets out, is considerably higher than for a standard word mark.

The Five Main Types of Non-Traditional Trademarks in UK Law

UK practice recognises five categories beyond standard word and logo marks, each represented differently on the register and each carrying a different level of registration difficulty. Sound and motion marks became far easier to file after the Trade Marks Regulations 2018 introduced electronic representation; smell marks remain effectively unregisterable in practice.

Type What it protects How it’s represented UK-relevant example Registration difficulty
Sound A jingle, chime or short audio sequence MP3 audio file or musical notation MGM’s lion roar; the Intel chime Moderate: achievable with a distinctive, non-generic sound
Colour A single colour or colour combination used consistently on goods Pantone reference plus a precise description Cadbury’s purple, Pantone 2685C Hard: requires strong evidence of acquired distinctiveness
Shape (3D) The shape of a product or its packaging Line drawings or photographs from multiple angles Nestle’s Kit Kat four-finger bar (refused) Very hard: shapes dictated by function are excluded
Smell An odour or scent associated with a product No accepted method since 2002 Sumitomo Rubber’s 1996 rose-scent tyre mark (pre-Sieckmann) Effectively impossible under current practice
Motion / multimedia A moving image, animation or on-screen sequence MP4 video file Animated device start-up sequences Moderate: same electronic filing route as sound marks

Can You Actually Register a Smell as a Trademark in the UK?

In practice, no. UK and EU trademark offices have not accepted a new smell mark application since the Court of Justice’s 2002 ruling in Sieckmann v Deutsches Patent- und Markenamt (Case C-273/00), which held that a scent must be represented clearly, precisely and objectively, something no chemical formula, written description or physical sample has yet managed to satisfy.

Before Sieckmann, a small number of scent marks did make it onto European registers. Dutch company Senta Aromatic Marketing registered “the smell of fresh cut grass” for tennis balls at the EU’s trademark office in 1996, and Japan’s Sumitomo Rubber Industries secured a UK registration the same year for a floral fragrance applied to tyres. Both predate the Sieckmann criteria and neither route has been open to new applicants since.

The Sieckmann criteria require any trademark representation to be clear, precise, self-contained, easily accessible, intelligible, durable and objective. Since the Court of Justice set this test in 2002, no smell mark has satisfied it at the UK IPO or the EU Intellectual Property Office, making scent effectively the one category the 1994 Act’s broad definition cannot currently deliver in practice.

[ORIGINAL ANALYSIS] The gap here is not the law’s definition of a trademark, which has always been broad enough to include smell, but the total absence of a technology that captures scent the way an MP3 file captures sound. Until an accepted digital scent-representation standard exists, advising a client to pursue a smell mark in the UK is advising them to spend money on an application examiners are almost certain to refuse.

How Did the 2018 Regulations Change the Game for Sound and Motion Marks?

The Trade Marks Regulations 2018 (SI 2018/825), in force from 14 January 2019, removed the old requirement that a mark be “represented graphically” and replaced it with a test that the sign be represented clearly enough for the registrar and the public to determine the exact scope of protection. That single change opened the register to MP3 and MP4 files for the first time.

Before 2019, a sound mark had to be reduced to musical notation on a stave, which was hopeless for anything that was not a short melody, such as a chime, a jingle stinger or a spoken phrase. After the 2018 Regulations, applicants could simply upload an audio file, and the IPO’s own register now displays an embedded player alongside many sound mark entries.

[SOLICITOR INSIGHT] Sound and motion marks are the non-traditional category we see succeed most often, precisely because the representation problem that sinks smell marks has already been solved by file format. The remaining hurdle is distinctiveness: a generic beep or a stock notification tone will not clear examination, but a genuinely original audio signature, used consistently across advertising, usually will.

  • Pre-2019: sound marks required musical notation, excluding most non-melodic sounds
  • Post-2019: MP3 files accepted, and video files accepted for motion and multimedia marks
  • Distinctiveness, not representation, is now the main barrier for sound and motion marks
  • Colour and shape marks still face the older, tougher distinctiveness tests described below

What Do the Cadbury and Kit Kat Cases Teach About Colour and Shape Marks?

Colour and shape marks face a stricter test than sound marks because consumers do not usually treat a colour or a product shape as a brand indicator without training. In Nestle v Cadbury UK Ltd [2017] EWCA Civ 358, the Court of Appeal refused Nestle’s attempt to register the four-finger Kit Kat bar shape, holding that recognising a shape is not the same as relying on it to identify who made the product.

Cadbury’s own long-running fight over the colour purple shows the same test applied the other way. In Societe des Produits Nestle SA v Cadbury UK Ltd [2022] EWHC 1671 (Ch), the High Court partially overturned an earlier refusal and allowed two of Cadbury’s three purple colour mark applications to proceed, tied to the specific Pantone reference 2685C used consistently on its chocolate packaging since the 19th century.

Cadbury’s UK colour mark for Pantone 2685C purple was allowed by the High Court in 2022 for two of its three applications, following a Court of Appeal refusal in 2013 of an earlier, more loosely worded version. The Kit Kat four-finger shape, by contrast, was refused registration by the Court of Appeal in 2017 because consumers were not shown to rely on the shape itself to identify the product.

[CAMBRIDGE PERSPECTIVE] We see the shape-mark problem most often with Cambridge hardware and product-design startups that assume a distinctive enclosure or product silhouette is automatically protectable. It is not, unless the founder can show years of consistent, prominent use of that exact shape as a brand signal, evidence that a two-year-old startup rarely has. A registered design right, which protects appearance without requiring acquired distinctiveness, is usually the faster and cheaper option at that stage.

Why Do Shape Marks Fail More Often Than Colour Marks?

Shape marks fail more often because UK law specifically excludes shapes that result from the nature of the goods themselves or that are necessary to achieve a technical result, an exclusion colour marks do not face in the same way. A chocolate bar shape that makes the product easier to break into pieces risks being seen as functional rather than brand-distinguishing, which is exactly the finding that sank Kit Kat.

UK Trademark Costs and Timelines at a Glance

A standard UK trademark application costs £170 for one class filed online, rising to £205 from 1 April 2026, and an unopposed application typically registers within three to four months. Non-traditional marks routinely take longer, since examiners more often raise objections on distinctiveness or clarity of representation before the application can proceed to publication.

  1. £170 (£205 from 1 April 2026): official filing fee for one class, online
  2. £60: each additional class beyond the first
  3. 3 to 4 months: typical time to registration if unopposed
  4. Around 5% of applications: attract a formal opposition during the two-month publication window
  5. Non-traditional marks: expect at least one examination report before publication is realistic

These figures cover the official fee only. For a colour, shape or sound mark, most of the real cost sits in preparing evidence of acquired distinctiveness, such as sales figures, advertising spend and consumer surveys, which a straightforward word mark rarely needs.

Is a Non-Traditional Trademark Worth It for Your Business?

For most SMEs, a non-traditional trademark is worth pursuing only once a sound, colour or shape has already become genuinely recognisable to customers through years of consistent use, not before. Filing early, before that recognition exists, usually just produces an examiner’s objection and a wasted fee.

The more reliable order of operations is to secure a standard word or logo mark first, since that protects the brand name itself quickly and cheaply, and treat a non-traditional filing as a later addition once there is real evidence a colour, sound or shape has become distinctive in its own right. You can draft the groundwork for a standard trademark application using the ApexCounsel document creator, then have a solicitor review the classification and distinctiveness position before you file, whether that is a conventional mark now or a non-traditional one further down the line.

If you are weighing up whether a colour, sound or shape your business relies on is actually registrable, or you need help assembling the distinctiveness evidence a non-traditional application requires, book a consultation with our team and we will give you a straightforward, transparently priced view of your options.

Frequently Asked Questions

Has any smell mark ever been successfully registered in the UK?

Yes, but only before the law tightened. Sumitomo Rubber Industries registered a rose-scent mark for tyres in the UK in 1996. No smell mark has succeeded since the Court of Justice’s 2002 Sieckmann ruling set representation standards that scent has not yet been able to meet.

Can a single colour ever function as a UK trademark?

Yes, but only with strong evidence that consumers already associate that specific colour, defined by an exact Pantone reference, with one business. Cadbury’s purple succeeded on this basis in 2022 after decades of consistent packaging use; most businesses without that history will struggle to clear the same bar.

Why was the Kit Kat shape refused as a UK trademark?

The Court of Appeal held in 2017 that while consumers recognised the four-finger shape, Nestle had not shown that consumers relied on the shape itself, rather than the wrapper or branding, to identify who made the product. Recognition alone is not enough; the shape must do the identifying work on its own.

Do sound marks need to be a full piece of music to register in the UK?

No. Since the Trade Marks Regulations 2018, a short chime, jingle stinger or even a single distinctive tone can be filed as an MP3 file, provided it is original enough to distinguish the business rather than sounding like a generic notification or alert tone.

Is it cheaper to register a design right instead of a shape trademark?

Often, yes, at least at an early stage. A UK registered design protects the appearance of a product without requiring proof that customers already rely on the shape as a brand indicator, which is the hurdle that most new shape trademark applications fail to clear.

How long does a non-traditional trademark application take compared with a standard one?

A standard word mark typically registers within three to four months if unopposed. Non-traditional marks usually take longer, because examiners more frequently issue at least one objection on distinctiveness or clarity of representation that has to be answered before the application can move to publication.

Investment in intangible assets, including intellectual property, reached £244.7 billion across the UK economy in 2023, up 6.3% on the previous year, according to the Office for National Statistics. Non-traditional trademarks are a small, difficult corner of that picture, but getting the underlying strategy right, word mark first, non-traditional protection only once distinctiveness is proven, is one of the cheaper steps available in protecting a growing brand. ApexCounsel’s IP services team can talk through whether your brand assets are ready for that next step.

More Insights